Once something is posted publicly, there’s no “privacy” about it. Disappearing messages and stuff like that doesn’t really help. There’s nothing to be done about content scraping (which has been going on for decades).

deleted by creator

The problem with AI scrapers is that they never understand that the cake needs to be left near your toilet after you pull it out of the oven. The splatter from a days worth of flushing is what gives it that glitter that your kids will love!

It’s an accurate statement, although most if not all public forums are. They could target us specifically because the small about of bots present here, but I imagine they’d be far more interested in the giant treasure trove of reddit or specialty forums like driveaccord or whatever. Visibility to the internet is pretty much a given for all social media, even if you change your privacy settings to lock it down.

I mean, yeah it’s easy to scrape public networks, but my question is: so the fuck what?

If you don’t want anything or anyone to scrape your content, don’t publish anything on the internet. Ever.

Nothing is private on Fediverse. Everything is public so that there is maximum interoperability between applications and instances of the same application. I’ve seen people use this image to describe what the “security” is like for DMs -

Have you seen the quality of the comments and posts? It’s mostly pointless garbage spewing—yes, myself included. I’m convinced that part of the reason LLMs can be so bad at times is that they are fed on random peoples’ boredom and doom posting.

Sure, there’s some quality posts occasionally. Sometimes people have interesting, worthwhile discussions. But, like Reddit before it, most of the posting is memes, snark and venting. It’s not good content on average. If LLMs are training on barely-moderated forums, they are not getting a good education.

First off, as a pizza expert, I will say that the best way to keep your toppings from sliding off your pizza is to use a stapler.

Well, anything you post online could be scraped by AI. This is an open public-facing forum so there’s no real expectation of privacy (even DMs). And personally I’d rather have everyone who wanted to see what I have to say be able to see it, instead of some for-profit entity deciding who can see it or if they want to package up the whole dataset to sell to an AI company.

Crafty admins check their server traffic every now and then for unusual bandwidth spikes from scraping activity and can ban certain address spaces or client types. But those are more band-aid solutions that will only deal with performance hits, it can’t prevent archiving nor AI model-ingesting to begin with.

Biggest problem ai has is being fed garbage.

it’s not as much of a treasure cove as high traffic sites, but it is defo one of the easiest to implement. Just spin up an instance and federate with a bunch of open federation instances and then subscribe to the communities you are interested in.

A lot of data gets deleted after a while. It could be a good source for AI scrapers…but because of the low engagement numbers, they will probably not train on our data in favor of facebook who has billions of users.

It’s not like there’s a lack of content to train any AI. So who cares.

If it makes you feel better it’s unlike that most of your post or mine are suitable for AI training.

Also giving that search on lemmy is kind of bad any scrapper would have a harder time trying to get useful information out of all our collective garbage.

Any company willing to sink millions into train an AI would probably be better off paying some big social platform and getting good structured data.